Detective Martinez traveled to Indiana in late 2012 and met with church elders in Elkhart County. They confirmed that “Joseph Miller” and his family had lived in their community from 1993 until 2001.
“He was quiet, kept to himself more than most,” recalls Bishop Samuel Bontrager. “He was a skilled carpenter, worked hard. The family seemed… burdened. Like they carried heavy weight. We respected their privacy.”
Joseph Miller—the man investigators now believed was Jacob Miller—died in February 2001 of a heart attack at age forty-eight. He was buried in the Amish cemetery under his assumed name.
His wife “Rebecca” and their children had moved shortly after his death, relocating to a Mennonite community in Kentucky, where record-keeping was even more sparse.
This meant Ruth Miller—if she’d survived—might still be alive.
Finding Ruth
Locating Ruth took another three months of investigation, working with Mennonite church contacts who connected Detective Martinez with progressive Mennonite communities in Kentucky.
In February 2013, Martinez found her.
Ruth Miller, now fifty-eight, was living in a small house near a Mennonite church in Bowling Green, Kentucky. She worked at a quilt shop, lived alone, and attended church regularly under the name Rebecca Stoltzfus.
When Martinez knocked on her door and gently explained that she knew Ruth’s true identity, Ruth’s response was immediate: she broke down crying.
